How the West was F1
Austin 2014
US Grand Prix
Step by step towards a Schumacher deal with Mercedes
News
Step by step towards a Schumacher deal with Mercedes
Posted By: James Allen  |  14 Dec 2009   |  10:59 pm GMT  |  113 comments

The latest twist in the story of Michael Schumacher’s move towards a comeback is Ferrari president Luca di Montezemolo saying that Ferrari’s consultancy agreement with Schumacher is not binding and they cannot hold him if he wants to race for “a competitor”.

Montezemolo: "....with regret...."
Sources in Germany suggest that Schumacher was not prepared to move forward with the comeback unless Montezemolo gave it his blessing and perhaps this was the purpose of today’s interview with Reuters. Schumacher is due to meet the Ferrari president later this week, apparently. My sources in Italy and Germany are now adamant that this deal is going to happen.

There will be more from Montezemolo on this as he is hosting a lunch for media representatives from around Europe on Thursday. Although he has expressed reservations privately about Schumacher moving to a rival company, which has launched a supercar into the same sector as Ferrari, Montezemolo said that their agreement is “not binding”.

“You can’t work with a competitor and with us at the same time,” he added.

For all the momentum that this comeback story has gained, fueled by the German media primarily, there still seem to have been some important things which have not yet taken place. Schumacher has yet to clear his medical checks, has yet to approach Montezemolo about moving on, and sponsors with whom Schumacher has commitments in 2010 have not been approached about his release.

“I still haven’t spoken to him about it,” the Ferrari president said. “He is only a dear friend, not a team member. He is a consultant for our road cars.”

Bild newspaper in Germany says that Schumacher is yet to undergo his neck scan at the Bad Nauheim clinic he uses for all his medical activities and claims that Mercedes wants him to test a 2007 car, as he did with Ferrari, to check on the status of his neck. This could still be a stumbling block and Schumacher does not want a repeat of the summer where he announced the comeback then found he could not deliver. Bernie Ecclestone is quoted as saying, “Let’s hope it happens this time,” having been left disappointed by Schumacher’s no show in August.

Intriguingly, Schumacher did not attend Ferrari’s Christmas party at the weekend and according to Gazzetta dello Sport, Montezemolo spoke about Raikkonen, Massa and Alonso but did not mention Schumacher.

Meanwhile Mercedes has suffered a blow today with a sponsor it thought it had landed, Henkel, revealing that the team has been scammed by a rogue employee who was not empowered to strike a deal which would have been worth many millions to the team. Henkel is a German conglomerate, operating in a wide range of sectors from adhesives to hair care and laundry products.

Featured News
MORE FROM JA ON F1...
Share This:
Posted by:
Category:
113 Comments
  1. Noelinho says:

    I was very hopeful in the summer of the Ferrari deal, and have always been hopeful of this, but more wishful thinking than anything.

    I would relish a Schumacher comeback and, if he does sign a contract, I will be arranging whatever overdraft I need for Silverstone! There’s no way I’m missing that!

    1. Josh says:

      well said.

    2. Paul Mc says:

      Can anyone advise on what tickets to get for Silverstone? Been watching F1 for 15 years and ive yet to get to a race, seen as its only a 30min flight from Dublin, the British GP is handy for me. No way am i missing Schumi!

  2. Simon Pearce says:

    This won’t happen. Or at least it shouldn’t happen! Why would he want to come back to a new team with an untested car? I think it would be a big mistake. An exciting one though!

    1. Phil says:

      It’s not a new team with an untested car though, is it? It’s simply the rebadged brawn/honda/BAR/Tyrrell team which will be building on last years double championship winning car (which was a frankencar from all accounts, designing from the word go around the Merc lump should give them tangible benefits).

  3. Brandon Merrell says:

    Has anyone considered whether Michael is interested in working with Mercedes in any capacity other than as a driver? That would still require him to sever his contract with Ferrari.

    Unlikely and out-of-character for Michael, I know, but I thought I’d throw it out there.

    1. Hannah says:

      future team management james?

  4. carlm21 says:

    I really hope this happens. I think Michael would still be capable of race wins given the car. He might get to 100 wins yet. At the end of the day he has nothing to prove and nothing to lose so it is worth a go. £7 million would tempt me, I drive a Ford Escort. Be good to see Ford in F1 again.

  5. Paul says:

    Although manufacturers have recently left and the world is broke, it looks to me as if the health of F1 is once again rude. It [F1] doesn’t need MS to return but is it hard to understand why he wants to? He misses it and, importantly, thinks he can still win races. Everyone reminisces.

  6. Peter says:

    By fate, (Button leaving Brawn, Mercedes taking over Brawn GP etc) this opportunity has arose for Schumacher. The Gods of F1 did this so Schumacher could return!

  7. Sebee says:

    I have to say, I appreciate the efforts paid in digging up the info on this for us fans.

    Gut feeling for me wasthat this made total sense. Champions always work with proven quantities, and you can’t be more proven than 7 championships for Schumi/Ross combo.

    As late as Italy, Brawn was a winning car, and even by the end when development was slowed/stopped it was still podium contending until the very end. The car will be good in 2010. Schumi will do what he does, and it will be like clockwork.

    I don’t have an F1 reputation like James to put on the line. But I’m going on record, Schumi will deliver a win in 2010 if he’s driving for Ross.

    Anyone who worries or doubts Schumi due to no refueling needs to look back only to Brazil 2006. He drove heavy on what ended up being equal to one stop strategy after his race start puncture. What he did after is legend like Keyser Soze :-) Back from “death” in his last race to 4th passing Kimi on his final lap right in front of my grandstand at Senna Esses – I still get chills.

  8. george debenham says:

    James, do you think there may be a possibility that this has been a long planned and covert plot by Brawn/Mercedes?
    Perhaps it was planned that Button would be disatisfied with a new contract conveniently clearing the way for ‘the surprise’ signing. I seem to recall that when Rosberg was announced he made strong indications that he was not expecting to presume the roll of team leader and this would be something he would be working towards over the next season. Did he already know that Schumacher would be joining him on a one season contract?
    Lets face it James more devious things than this have happened in F1 before.

    1. James Allen says:

      Did they think of this before Button started looking at McLaren? Quite possibly. Schumacher was up for driving again over the summer and someone (Willi Weber?) told Eddie Jordan about it pretty early on.

      1. Hannah says:

        James, with so much feedback on Eddie Jordan, can you pass comment on his current involvement in F1 (commentating etc), plus is there any chance of EJ returning to the helm of a team?

        I for one enjoyed his work with the beeb, he’s got personality!

      2. dale says:

        No no no, Jordon No bring back James to partner Brundle again.
        Any chance James :?:

    2. F1 Fan says:

      I reckon there is no doubt that this plan was hatched sometime after MS agreed to fill in for Massa and his obvious desire to return to f1 was exposed. It was probably also around the same time Ross Brawn realised that although Button was a very good driver he is not of the calibre of MS. All of this probably coincided with Mercedes decision to buy Brawn as well as Button realisation that it would be better to be beaten by Lewis than Rosberg.

      I think that sums it up.

  9. Boneshark187 says:

    I don’t think Mercedes will have any troubles finding a sponsor if this news is true.

  10. rossetto says:

    The fake Henkel deal, may become a roadblock for MS swapping to Mercedes.
    Missing 30 millions euros a year is not peanuts.

  11. Roberto says:

    Dear James,

    I think this deal is coming from some time, Montezemolo knew it and that´s why he was pushing for a third car. MS has been raining very hard and racing karts all over the world, so i think he is looking forward to racing again. You better than knows that this kind of deals doesn´t come from one day to another, this could have been in the making for some time.

    Let´s hope his neck is fit enough to race, the prospect of having 4 world champions racing is amazing. I recognize i will have problems cheering for Massa and Schumacher

  12. Alistair Blevins says:

    How does one best prepare a hat to eat? I fear I’ll be eating mine before the week is out.

    1. Louis says:

      Do share the recipe if you get one, I’ve said (although only to myself, and not with 100% certainty) the same.

      I guess rationality/sanity doesn’t always win. I guess that’s what makes F1 fun.

      1. john g says:

        i’m going to eat a lasagne hat :)

    2. Stephen Kellett says:

      That depends on the type of hat you are going to eat. Do tell.

  13. RceKid says:

    “Mercedes wants him to test a 2007 car, as he did with Ferrari, to check on the status of his neck”

    That car would be Honda 2007 am I right?
    If so this test can both be tricky and funny to watch.

    1. James Allen says:

      Not necessarily. I don’t think they would be able to get the engines, for a start. It will be whoever can loan them a fairly recent car, possibly a private owner

      1. Sam says:

        James I don’t understand how it works?
        We are talking about a 7 times champion why does he need to loan? i thought he own all the F1 Ferrari(s) he raced with?

        As for the Ferrari Christmas party, do you think there is a change of relationship between Luca and himself?

        I personally don’t think anyone at Ferrari can be mad at him.

    2. J.M. says:

      Maybe they can grab an old Brawn GP car from the 90′s and fit a Mercedes Benz engine in it. I think it was called BGP001 or something…

      ;)

  14. Still left feeling quite uneasy about all this. What about the Ferrari family that Schumacher has always spoken about? It would all be scuppered in one move forever. Shame.

    1. Surely most of “the family” have already left Ferrari or retired by now..?

    2. Elliot says:

      But many of the key players from his era are already gone (Todt, Brawn).

    3. Steve says:

      I have the same feeling. I would love to see him come back but in a Ferrari

  15. Matt says:

    All practicalities of the decision aside, I think this could really be something which reinvigorates genuine interest and excitement back into F1.

    For me, as a hardened F1 fan, last season was great. Button’s blistering the start, controversy, racing excitement (relative to other years), drama (trulli v sutil for one) and Hamilton/Barrichello’s spirited comeback in the second half of the season.

    But if you consider the ‘ordinary’ person, who may be a floating F1 fan, having a personality like Michael back in the sport could really give F1 the boost it needs after some of the controversies and low points which have tarnished it’s reputation in the last couple of seasons. I know Michael isn’t flashy or excitable like Jenson or Lewis, and he has had his fair share of controversy, but to have a genuine talent like his back in the sport can only be a good thing.

    1. Frank says:

      How ironic. When Michael was winning, lots of critics saying that the Ferrari/Schumacher domination drove away the fans.

      Now F1 need Michael to bring back the people interest back in F1?

  16. F1 Fan says:

    I cant believe this is actually going to happen. I believe Schumacher’s return will be great for Mercedes, F1 and the fans alike. To see a living legend return to the track will be very exciting.
    I know some people have said that this can only harm his legacy, I personally believe it will only enhance to the enigma that is Michael Schumacher. Win or Loss he’s a champ and you have to admire someone who is prepared to back his own abilities in the fastest cars against the best driver’s on earth.

    I know I’ll be buying my tickets to see his return.

  17. Med says:

    With Merc apparently losing $80m from the Henkel deal being fraudulent, they probably could do with getting Schumacher onboard to win over the sponsors – it’s hardly the start they needed seeing as they were trumpeting how much money could be saved in the new F1 era.

  18. Maria says:

    “Schumacher did not attend Ferrari’s Christmas party at the weekend and according to Gazzetta dello Sport, Montezemolo spoke about Raikkonen, Massa and Alonso but did not mention Schumacher”

    This bit is telling. It doesn’t matter if the deal is done or not by now, it just proves that there is intent on both sides (Schumacher/Mercedes)

  19. Richard says:

    This is a win win for Merc. People seem to doubt that he can compete, but this is MS we are talking about. Reunited with his old partner, Ross Brawn, and sparks could fly on track. Interesting though that if true, FA now has a Schumacher free zone at Ferrari which must please him. Or does it? We can only wonder.

    1. Schumi says:

      Cannot underestimate the partnership in brawn/schumacher. incredible prospect.

      1. Michael C says:

        is that you Michael? – seriously I hope he comes back and does so convincingly – but times have obviously changed on the salary front

  20. JoeE says:

    It’s a done deal as long as all the cards fall into place we will see MS at the wheel of a MGP-001

    I didn’t like him when he was on the grid before but this is good for f1 to take away from the manufractures leaving at least.

    James no word on henkel leaving mclaren??

    Also can you get some info from bernie about HD coverage. We all know you have him in speed dial :)

    Cheers

  21. Howard Hughes says:

    I’m at a loss as to why Schumacher should show any such loyalty to Montezemelo; correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t it common knowledge by now that he effectively ousted Schumacher from the team in favour of Raikkonen, forcing him out before he wanted to retire?

    So why now seek his ‘blessing’ before returning to the sport as a competitor?!

    1. Tarek says:

      I agree. But Michael seems to be a decent guy. Also, maybe Schumi might want to go back to his old role at Ferrari after his brief stint driving for Mercedes ends?

  22. Tom - Australia says:

    Sounds like it is going to happen. James, can we assume you have spoken with the man himself but are not able to divulge anything?

    What are peoples predictions on where Schuey will finish in the WDC?

    I’ll say 5th. Above Rosberg.

    1. James Allen says:

      Too early to say until we see the cars testing

    2. jose says:

      You are asking the imposible from allen.
      If we put lauda as a yardstick, even if it happened 28 years ago. When lauda returned in 1982, he won the us gp west at long beach, the third race of the year. Will the kaiser beat that?

    3. dale says:

      If Rosberg doesn’t beat his teammate then his stock will fall and he may end up being just another Webber or Trulli 8)

      1. F1 Fan says:

        I agree with comments regarding Rosberg and I believe Schuey will beat him, however that will not put in the same category as Webber. This year webber was almost a match for Vettel and he started the season with substantial injuries. Webber has always beaten his team mates unless I’m mistaken.

  23. Terry Hall says:

    James, Don’t you believe that Mercedes would have announced their second driver long ago if Schumacher were not a serious option?

  24. Pete Schnabel says:

    How can Mercedes ask him to test an ’07 car when those actually belong to McLaren?

    1. jose says:

      A honda it’s going to be.

      1. Pete Schnabel says:

        None of the old cars have any powertrains. Honda collected them all! To fit a Merc is out!

        I read that article 22.1a i) of the sporting regs ’09 allow a current racecar to be driven for “promotional” purposes with special “demonstrational” tires. This is how Luca Badoer got to drive an F60 in Fiorano before his debut in Valencia. Officially it was referred to as a day of “filming”. Schumacher could benefit this way as well.

  25. I hope Michael has learned from his no show last season. It’s best if Merc announce the deal after he’s 100% sure.

  26. Steve says:

    The really interesting point of this much publicised story is the effect it will be having on Nico Rosberg. Here is a young driver that during the announcement of his move expected to be a leader in the team and able to make his mark in a new team with a (hopefully) competitive car.

    He must be secretly hoping that this does not happen as nobody as yet to be an equal driver in the same team as Mr Schumacher.

    Mercedes will want to ensure the Michael has that first win and bets have to be on the table for a swing toward Micheal in this team just to justify the publicity and costs.

    Of course publicly Nico will relish the chance of racing against a 7 times world champion on equal terms etc. but you got to wonder how much sleep Nico is loosing over this particular challenge.

    1. Nicollers says:

      I thought this too. Especially after hearing today how “delighted” Rosberg would be if Schumacher were to join him at Mercedes. He must have thought that he would be THE German face to front the team.

      Personally though, even if Schumacher gets the lion’s share of the publicity and team expertise, I think Rosberg will fair better overall. Schumacher will be way off the pace for the first few races at least and Rosberg should be good from the get go.

      I’m trying to work out what this means long term for F1? To be honest I’m stumped. All I can picture to myself at the moment is on the last day of the 2010 season, Schumacher crashing into Alonso deliberately to stop him winning the title!

      Queue zoom-in on to Montezemolo’s face!

      ;oD

      1. DK says:

        Schumacher will not be way off the pace of Rosberg, no way. Shumacher is a very inteligent racer and will out perform him in the races for sure. Rosberg is a good driver and puts in quick single laps as we saw in practice sessions this year, but he is not in the same league as shumacher. I guess Schumacher would fancy his chances against any F1 driver in the same car other than the likes of Lewis, Alonso and Vettel. Rosberg will learn a lot from the Schumi and give him a real measure as to his true ability. It will be great to watch.

      2. Nicollers says:

        He will be. He’ll be rustier than an old junkyard Studebaker….

  27. Tarek says:

    All seems to be falling into place now. Good thing that Montezemolo is showing a sense of decency. I wonder, though, whether Michael signing for Mercedes means that there is no possibility for him ever returning to the Ferrari team in some capacity. Does this all mean that Schumacher will assume a similar role at Mercedes as the one he has filled for Ferrari in the last three years when he (again) hangs up his helmet? Or is he still a Ferrari man in the long term?

    1. CptZorg says:

      One would have to assume there would be no going back to Ferrari after such a high profile switch. The only association I can see him having with a prancing horse if this thing is for real is just the horse’s head under his sheets.

      MS didn’t make such an impact on the pitwall for Ferrari but perhaps it could be different with RB? If that doesn’t work out, he’ll probably stay with Merc in an advertising capacity if they can figure out how to polish his on track antics to fit Merc’s safe image.

  28. Arun Srini says:

    Lets hope it happens this time!

  29. LossBlawn says:

    As a McLaren supporter, I’d love to see Micheal back, and hopefully he’ll have a car to atleast compete at the front.

    Epic battles I hope!!

  30. Richard says:

    If “Mercedes want him to test a 2007 car” then that’s the end of the deal. Remember it will be a 2007 Honda. He’ll do half a lap then park it and stomp off like the Stig losing his temper with a Lancia!

    1. Mario says:

      It wasn’t a Lancia, it was a replica Lancia Stratos kit car, but I get your point.

  31. Mario says:

    So, the great Michael Schumacher wants to come back to the front line action? If he really is then maybe I’ll have a chance to see the good Michael, not the cheating one as I remember him since 1994.

    1. jose says:

      when he gets on racing mode, i think you’ll see the “take no prisoners type”. If he changed, he wouldn’t be the winner he was during those years.

  32. Monktonnik says:

    I am a massive Schumacher fan, and I am very excited about a return to F1. I can’t help feeling that losing the association with Ferrari road cars would be a shame. Saying that, with Alonso at Ferrari I guess it would only be a matter of time before his services were dispensed with completely.

    I wonder if Ferrari and especially LdM value MSC as much as they used to.

  33. Dale says:

    The Henkel story is amazing, how on earth could have happened :?:
    Is this likely to have repercussions for the Brawn team and the sum Mercedes paid for the team :?:

    As for the will he won’t he, I for one am getting bored with it and it wouldn’t surprise me either way, the trouble with F1 is that often it’s not all what it seems.

    Although off topic I wish I didn’t have to come across anything to do with Mosley. the spin he’s putting on the whole breakaway …………… I for one think FOTA may have missed their chance to ensure, we the fans are served a show worth watching (all too often it’s not, with many of the tracks just boring to beyond boring) 8)

  34. Rudy Pyatt says:

    So it seems his health alone can stop this. I assume that the Henkel money will be quickly replaced by another sponsor, if they don’t reverse themselves and put up the cash anyway, rogue employee or not, knowing that Schumacher (medical checks permitting) is in the team.

    Indulge me in a conspiracy theory here James. Assume Michael gets the medical all-clear and comes back. Given that Keke Rosberg seems to despise MS, what’s your take on him geting Nico away from the Silver Arrows and into a seat with whoever buys out Renault? Are there any get-out clauses in his contract that have been making the rumor mill?

    The Rosbergs are tough hombres, and Keke hasn’t (from what I’ve heard to date anyway) been a stage parent for him the way the Piquets have done it. But I just can’t see Ross and company allowing any possibility of Keke’s venom to infect the team through his son; it just creates too many opportunities for tension and distraction. Mercedes has been dealing with Anthony Hamilton’s presence and influence at McLaren as it is, so I seriously doubt that Norbert Haug relishes the prospect of another dose of that from Keke.

    The consensus seems to be that Merc’s ultimate target is Vettel anyway, so I’ll go out on a limb and connect the dots thus:

    Merc pays Nico to go to Renault (Toleman?) for the 2010 season, partnering Kubica. Renault engines being in the Red Bull, Nico maintains that connection by going to Red Bull, replacing Vettel there, when Seb moves to Merc in 2012. Until Vettel arrives, Heidfeld goes to Mercedes to partner Schumacher, a sound move as it gets another excellent development driver into the team who will reliably score points, and maybe more, given the likely strength of the car- in essence, a rerun of the Schumacher/Brawn/Barichello lineup. And it would be doubly appropriate, given that Heidfeld (correct me if I’m wrong on this), like MS, was groomed in the Mercedes junior team.

    Mind you, Kobyashi is still out there. If Nico and Keke have any ideas about a (whatever it morphs into) Renault seat, they should hop it quickly. A Kubica/Kobyashi lineup would be a formidable combination. And so would Vettel/Kobyashi down the line…

    1. James Allen says:

      It will be interesting. Rosberg is there on merit, selected by Mercedes and Ross.

      1. jose says:

        I can’t agree on this one. His nationality more than his results, gave him the seat at mercedes. He was helped a lot to get where he is now. He has done some things on the track, but he is still chasing his first win. He won championships on his way to f1, but so did piquet, with the best equipment money can buy. But when they get to f1, they have to deliver, and he is having problems to do so. Even with all his father expertise, you can’t buy talent.
        I remember his father sayng a few years back, during a kart race, that only hamilton and nico will get too f1, because of dennis and himself. He did his job, now is nico’s turn.
        Now everything is in place. He has to beat Michael schumacher. He has to finish him, and send him back to corina.
        And now keke can’t help anymore.

      2. Tarek says:

        I don’t think Nico necessarily has to beat Michael Schumacher. If he manages to keep Schumi honest, that will be just fine, and it will no doubt enhance his reputation and probably ensure that he remains at Mercedes in the long-term. Michael also doesn’t need to beat Rosberg, because if he doesn’t we will all understand that it has to do with age. So in a sense it’s a perfect scenario for both. Neither should feel the enormous pressure of having to beat the other, though Schumacher, admittedly, will be under slightly more pressure to deliver, given his status as the most successful driver of all-time.

      3. Dale says:

        I don’t rate him, good but not the best or in the top draw and maybe not even as fast as Webber 8)

    2. john g says:

      looks like kobayashi is going to sauber…

  35. Pierre says:

    “James Allen on F1
    2009: a revolutionary year”

    Oh yes!!!

    1. John F says:

      It may be 2010 before we know the end of this ;-)

  36. **Paul** says:

    If this happens (as I believe it will) I think many on here should be apologising to a certain Eddie Jordan. His views were totally dismissed by many people both on here and in the motoring press. Whilst I’m not a great fan of Eddie he does appear to have someone on the inside of every team up and down the paddock to base his judgement upon rather than solely relying on PR people.

  37. Spyros says:

    Apparently, the announced changes in the points’ system for 2010 have annoyed some stats’ gatherers – past changes have already made their life difficult when comparing drivers of different eras, but as changes in these things go, the latest one is a biggy.

    As far as I’m concerned, it is a good thing. I hate discussions about who was the greatest, Clark or Senna, Gilles Villeneuve or Ascari, etc – etc. These discussions lead nowhere, except maybe the issues of chivalry and safety (or the lack thereof).

    This is why I am so dissappointed with these news. I was a Schumacher fan. I really liked the man, partly because I felt the media was usually harsh with him, but mainly because compared to other sportsmen and women earning similar amounts of money, he seemed to have his feet on the ground. Sure, he made the odd ‘unsportsmanlike’ maneuvre, but what would F1 be like if everyone in it was polite?

    I wrote that “I was” a Schumacher fan, as opposed to “I am”, because since his retirement my focus is elsewhere. I believe the current crop of Formula 1 drivers has a lot of talent in it. I am looking forward to see who will emerge on top in 2010, between the newer guys like Rosberg and Vettel, or the slightly older ones, like Alonso and Hamilton (is it OK to call Hamilton a ‘seasoned driver’ in 2010?).

    I hope ‘Schu’ stays retired. If he absolutely needs to race, maybe he can invite some old friends/enemies, like Hakkinnen, Coulthard, Irvine, Hill and Villeneuve and make an “Old Boys’ Championship”, as a Friday fixture before every GP: they could race last year’s cars in a ‘sprint’ race (10-15 laps). I’m sure Bernie would love to promote the event, and the new FIA president wouldn’t object!

    OK I admit I’m day-dreaming.

    Maybe the return, if it happens, is nothing more than an excuse for Michael to promote Merc road cars, instead of Ferraris, but I still hate it. It is just like remakes of old films: the new kids watching them may think they’re OK, but they just ruin our memories of the originals.

    1. Schumi says:

      its a new day, a schumacher return would be quite different to a bad rehash like the italian job.

  38. Kakashi says:

    now may b i get it as to y Ferrari had been calling for a 3rd car.. may b Schumi expressed his desire for racing again and that was Ferrari’s attempt to give him a race…

  39. Dave Smith says:

    I’d say the silence on the comeback from the Schumacher camp says it all! After all when he announced the comeback (which failed in the summer) it made him look silly when his neck was still dodgy. At least if he doesnt pass a medical this time, the Schumacher camp can turn round and say we never said Michael was coming back it was the media – where as if he passes the test it can be anounced. Once bitten twice shy as they say??

  40. rpaco says:

    Since he was not at the Ferrari Christmas do, it means that he did not want to spend the entire evening being asked if it were true. If it were definite that he were staying, then he would have gone to the party.
    So now he cannot stay, if he wanted to, his loyalty to the family is broken. So I guess he has to go now, if not to Brawn Mercedes than to another team but for pocket money only. The loss of a Brawn sponsor will be a significant blow since it would have paid for Schumi and left change.
    I still think that this is one of Schumi’s worst decisions, he will be slow at the start of the season, the time when opinions are being formed as to if he is past it or not.
    His reactions are still lightening fast but a few hundredths slower than before, a bit more brain will need to be used that was previously in reserve, he may only be as good as the rest now.

  41. Crom says:

    Anyone think Jean Todt has been involved in this somehow?

    A Schumacher comeback would certainly get his new F1 reign off to a flying start. I get the sense there may be strings being pulled, influence exerted. Brawn and Todt went from Ferrari to greater challenges, now Schumacher, it seems, may follow.

    1. Tarek says:

      Jean Todt maybe. Bernie Ecclestone definitely.

  42. Matt Ash says:

    Schumacher should not come back because he has already proved he is the greatest F1 driver ever. One question, what your predictions for the 2010 F1 line-up?

  43. Attila says:

    Hi James,

    What do you think, will Rosberg have chance to beat Schumacher?
    And are there any other sponsor deals on the board of Mercedes? :)

    Thanks!

  44. HotKARLTHoroddsen says:

    Mercedes needs to avoid a repeat of the debacle they had with Henkel, and stop any negotiations that a junior employee has had with Willi Webber and contact Chip Ganassi immediately, even offering to pay for his First Class air ticket to Germany for contract talks to gain the services of Juan Pablo Montoya.

    At 41, Schumacher is too old to be leading the Silver Arrows team in their inaugural year in F1 and with the strongest driver in F1 and best qualifier since Senna, Juan Pablo Montoya has youth and an excess of rugged manliness necessary to lead the Silver Arrows to the WDC and WCC in 2010.

    1. Dan says:

      Montoya likes NASCAR because the cars are big enough inside to accomodate him… He won’t come back to F1, he likes burgers and America too much…

    2. Neil Williams says:

      As much as I love JPM (and I watch NASCAR pretty much because of his participation in that championship) I fear his rugged manliness has been blunted a little by good American cooking and sponsors free coke/pepsi!

      A great talent lost from F1 and one that is now getting used to the unique demands of NASCAR. The chase this year, maybe next regular winner and the chase and 2011 the title?

    3. Skid says:

      Didn’t McLaren build a “supersize” car for our Nige a few years back? I think they should offer it to Mercedes in case JPM arrives with his helmet.

    4. Alex says:

      JPM will likely not be able to fit in an F1 car and he always seemed happier in the US than in F1. And also, I bet that 41-years old MS is fitter than NASCAR-bound JPM.

    5. Tarek says:

      Montoya had his chance in 2003 and blew it by making several misjudgements during the course of the season, despite having probably the fastest car on most circuits. He’s very fast but he’s reckless and doesn’t possess the qualities that made Schumi great. Even in terms of pace, Kimi showed him the way when they were together at McLaren. Besides, I think he’s happy in NASCAR right now and wouldn’t fancy an F1 return.

  45. David Whitworth says:

    I have never been a Schumacher fan, but I am very excited about the possibility of his return to F1. What surprises me when I have been reading the comments on this and previous blog’s relating to Michael’s come back, is the amount of people not understanding his return? I think I have got it, are they disgruntled Ferrari fans? Something happened this summer when Massa was injured and Schumacher held his hand up to drive again for Ferrari. I think Michael was probably the most disappointment of all parities concerned (team, fans, etc). Since then the driver contacts have affectively been put on hold (until very recently) with only Alonso having been signed just before Massa’s crash. There was the call from Ferrari, for teams to be allowed to run three cars and also Jenson’s Buttons move to McLaren. Did Jenson’s learn who his team mate might be at Brawn/Mercedes and choose the lesser of two evils, the lesser being Lewis H. as team mate?
    Schumacher, coming back to F1 has got to be a good thing. He is the man to beat and so much has been said of Hamilton and Vettel, if he returns it will be a great bench mark for everyone. As for why he wants to return, I would love to drive a F1 car as would many others, so why not, just drive and have fun. Let hope it’s a good one and here’s to 2010.

    1. Brian Martin says:

      Agree about Button not wanting to team with Michael. If you are on a team with Michael and Ross, you know you are the second driver.

      Michael is great. A return may be great for the fans. However, I don’t think enough credit is given to the existing drivers, some who have improved quite a bit since Michael left. Perhaps his comeback is better left to the imagination. I think the Shuey fans will be disappointed mid-season if Brawn doesn’t have another killer car.

    2. Dan says:

      Re: Button choosing the lesser of two evils… I don’t think this was the case, as Mercedes had Rosberg signed up a long time before that…

  46. Hairs says:

    Fascinating stuff if it does happen for a number of reasons:

    1) Ferrari will lose one of their biggest marketing tools.

    2) Nico Rosberg will be effectively stunted when this happens. He moved out of Williams in what was a great career move to Brawn. That is now dead in the water, he won’t be able to progress or win races as Schuey’s #2.

    3) Ross Brawn was very vocal all year that Brawn is a different team, it is run to *his* philosophy, there would be no return to the shady practices of the Ferrari days etc – where does this put him now? Does anyone really believe Schumacher will allow equal status, or share setups, or behave in any way that isn’t… “Schumacheresque” for euphemism’s sake.

    4) What on EARTH is going to happen to Nick Fry now? Signing a 3 year sponsorship deal with a convicted fraudster without doing due diligence or verifying contracts? He gets a lot of heat from fans who assume he’s not up to the job, whether they have facts to back it up or not. This, if true, is incredible. Would like to hear your thoughts on the subject James.

    1. scott bloom says:

      Chris–great picture!

  47. I wonder if Nico realised he would be signing up to play second fiddle to Schumacher [if he signs up] instead of measuring himself against Jenson [who he thought would be his team mate] and being allowed to race for wins, looks like his F1 career is about to stall, as none of Schumachers previous ‘running mates’ have managed to go on as a team leader / world champion.

  48. Craig says:

    Phone rings:
    RB. hey michael, ross here.
    MS. hey ross. How’s things?
    RB. Not good. We lost jenson to mclaren.
    MS. Bugger.
    RB. Got any plans for next year?
    MS. Well not really. Why’s that?
    RB. Seems I’m in need of a driver. Moneys not great though.
    MS. Ross, I’m insulted. I don’t need money. Tell ya what. You let me in on how you got your roses to thrive while you were on “gardening leave” and we have a deal.
    RB. sounds good. We just won’t announce it yet. Build up some hype. I’ve got a feeling Nick just made a bad business deal so we should wait and use this to take the heat off the team if it goes bad.
    MS. Ok. I better ask the misses if I’m allowed.
    RB. Good luck with that. Talk later. Bye
    MS. Bye
    Click.
    Perhaps it was that easy!!!

  49. Robert McKay says:

    Rosberg must have expected to move to Brawn/Merc to pair up with a world champion Jenson Button, since we all knew this was going to happen aeons before it was announced.

    Reasonably then he never expected to be de facto number 1, and more likely expected that he would have to prove himself as better than Button over a period of time to become the effective team leader.

    Schumacher coming in might actually be a bonus for him. It removes some of the pressure on Rosberg – does he really want to be seen as team leader in the current world champion car, right from the off in 2010? Perhaps if it’s clearly dominant, but not if it’s struggling to live with Mclarens/Red Bulls/Ferraris.

    But a Schumacher there will hide Rosberg from that a bit. Even if he does come back it’s not going to be forever. Gives Nico time to establish himself in the team, potentially pick up a win or two in a good car, and then be the incumbent if/when Vettel comes across.

    I think Nico’s good and deserves a Merc drive (though not necessarily the lead seat), but clearly Nakajima is not a yardstick. Nico’s career so far has had the stage-managed feel of a boxer’s career, where they carefully choose each fight and the big guns try to avoid each other until unavoidable so as to all maintain strong records.

    It’s worked so far but at some point he’s going to have to come up against a big name in the same team. There are too many big names in F1 with too few strong drives to make it unavoidable.

    1. Tarek says:

      Yeah, we’ll see what Rosberg is made and surely Michael coming back can’t hurt Nico’s chances of improving further and blossoming into a truly first-rate driver, because he probably has the pace for it.

    2. Rich C says:

      Well, if it happens, then maybe he’ll learn something from the Great Man just by following him around.

  50. Chris Crawford says:

    Me too!

  51. Flintelli says:

    I’m a huge FERRARI fan, the prospect of Schumacher joining Ferrai in the summer was brilliant. Got to be honest would love to see him racing again even if it is in a Merc. Would be great for F1 – plain and simple. It may also force me to pay to stupid amoound of money Silverstone are insisting on! ha

  52. Adam D says:

    Good article James, it’s a fascinating story that at first i didn’t believe due to the fact that i thought Schumacher was 100% loyal to Ferrari and wouldn’t feel the need to possibly race again after his back problems ruled him out of replacing Felipe this year.

    If he does get the drive, it’d be intresting to see what his testing times are in the tests in the new year and how he handles the pressure as most people will think he can win the championship next year.

    Also did an article on this last night, obviously not as trustworthy as yours with your links in the sport, but it conveys the same message. http://sporttradesreport.blogspot.com/2009/12/michael-schumacher-what-his-return.html

  53. Scott Bloom says:

    I wish Michael would not come back. With rare exceptions, comebacks are a disaster, leaving the ex-champion looking diminished. http://wp.me/pIux9-3V

  54. Ethan X says:

    I personally dont believe Schumacher will come back for just 1 year , but 2 seasons or even 3 seasons sounds more realistic.

    Imagine if Schumacher won the drivers title in 2010 , and then retired … that would be the second time that the no 1 wont be on Brawns car, since button will be bringing his no1 sticker to mclaren next year …

    (ps Hello James , I am a die-hard MS fan from montreal CAN, as u can see and I have read your book “Michael Schumacher the edge of greatness” … however I was very ticked off when you wrote that Schumacher realized that Alonso was actually better than him …i dont buy that for a second. For FA to be better than MS he would have to be better than Hamilton too , which proved not to be the case in 2007 . How was FA better than Schumacher, besides being younger ….

    1. Tarek says:

      In terms of driving consistently over the course of the 2005-2006 seasons, Fernando was actually better than Michael. But some of Michael’s drives during 2006 (China for example) were still quite brilliant, and Schumi’s greatest drives are beyond anything that Alonso can produce. And in terms of raw speed and racecraft, I don’t think Alonso would have ever been a match for Schumacher at his peak (in equal cars, that is).

  55. Roger says:

    So, the general concensus I have read is that MS is “bored” and needs more action.. I reckon the only action he is going to see is all the young guns racing past him. Hamilton and Vettel will be all over him, and it will be interesting to see how Massa and Alonso size up to him. I am not convinced its a good move in a sportsman sense, but as always in F1 cash is king……

  56. john g says:

    how much info will schumacher have about the 09 ferrari – was he involved at all in its development? if so, i can’t see why ferrari would let him go and take all that knowledge to a competitor.

    as far as comebacks go, he has nothing to lose. do people think any less of people like muhammed ali or michael jordan, or do they just rememeber the good times?

    1. Skanda says:

      Knowledge on 09 car!!! – LdM will be happy to part with that and getting it implemented at Mercedes. The Ferrari 09 was a dud!

  57. Dave P says:

    The thing that will upset Luca and Ferrai most, is not the whole Family image or his loyalty etc.. But the Last 3 years he has tetsted and developed their road cars… think how much insider knowledge he has… every nuance of those cars he carry whithin him.

    Now he can go to Merecedes and truly guide them with their road car program to produce a better car than Ferrari…

    Now that has to really hurt Ferrari and Luca

LEAVE A COMMENT

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Top Tags
SEARCH News
JA ON F1 In association with...
Download the chequered flag podcast today
Download the chequered flag podcast today
Multi award winning Formula One photographer
Multi award winning Formula One photographer