Posted on May 15, 2009
Good week/Bad week | James Allen on F1 – The official James Allen website on F1

Good week for:

Jenson Button – Four wins from five, only four points dropped. He’s running out of people to challenge him for the title.

Ferrari – Took a huge step closer to the front with the updated car in Spain and decided to got for it and take a stand on 2010 rules. Let’s hope it doesn’t end in tears.

Kleenex – Jenson Button’s mother, Simone, attended the Spanish GP and revealed that that she cries every time he wins.

Oversized handluggage – Brawn has now won 11 trophies in the first five races

Bad week for:
Rubens Barrichello – His best chance to win a race this season, went away from him. He has an uneasy feeling of deja vu..

Sebastian Vettel – It is a sign of how far he has come that fourth in Spain is a disappointment. But he could have won the last three races and he knows that his starts are a big part of why he hasn’t.

Toro Rosso: Rule number one of Italian motoring is, “What’s behind me is not important.” However rule number two is “Don’t hit your team mate at the start of the race.”. Toro Rosso media department had a very short press release to write.

TV execs who don’t understand F1 – They will be looking nervously at their contracts, wondering what the viewing figures might do without Ferrari next year.

Formula 1 – Well it is, isn’t it?

Posted by:
Category:
Tags:
Good week/Bad week
43 Responses

  1.   1. Posted By: Wingers
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 8:55 am 

    It has been a shocking week for F1 yes…

    I hate that two men (I know there are more involved but these are the public figures), are playing Casino Royale level stakes with a sport they seem to think they own.

    Wrong.. The Fans do, so stop messing us around, we foot the bills so you can buy football clubs and perform unimaginable stunts in expensive hotels with radical connotations.

    I think I speak for many if not all, we are tired of having the sport pulled through the dirt, and sick of the word GATE. SpyGATE, liarGATE, diffuserGATE now stupid-proposals-without-checking-with-the-guys-that-actually-run-the-teams-and-foot-the-billGATE, begs you to think what-the****nextGATE!!!

    Just stop it, we watch the sport so we can get our minds off Political demeanours in the news, not to become fledging members of it, if thats what you want, I’ll happily provide my banking details so I can receive government grants and backhand deals too!!

    In case Bernie and Max you have forgotten. We are watching some of the finest engineering feats with wheels that race around the track, for the pure excitement and enjoyment of what happens on the track not behind closed doors. If I wanted to watch something Mickey Mouse, I’d watch A1GP, Indy or go to Disneyworld.

    From an incredibly disgruntled FAN who hasn’t missed and F1 race for 16 years!

    Listen to the FOTA, they make the sport what it is, not you, I don’t see an FIA owned team in the pack, and Brabham is long since gone…

    [Reply]


  2.   2. Posted By: Jon W
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 8:55 am 

    A good week for Ferrari?!

    You mean apart from the Kimi quali aberation and not putting enough fuel in Massa’s car?

    Maybe they should have been in both categories?

    [Reply]


  3.   3. Posted By: Kirk
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:00 am 

    Easyjet must be cashing in on all these Brawn GP wins then. :-)

    [Reply]


  4.   4. Posted By: Richard Mee
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:13 am 

    Wingers… 100% with you on the gate thing. makes me boil with rage whenever i read it… is the intention to be funny? to demonstate journalistic wit? I don’t know… but it’s had its day.

    PLease James make a stand and never ever use it as a postfix for anything ever again ; )

    Money though. That’s what it’s about now. You try to talk to Bernie about actual racing and he’ll give you a ‘you know nothing’ smile and wave you away.

    Truth is that there is so much money needing to be paid back out of the sport at the moment that there really is very little room to manouver. It’s now a big powerplay, and it’s got to the stage of winner takes all. This will end either in manufacturers dropping out or something fundamental breaking in FOM/FIA grip over the sport.

    If you ask me they need to wipe the slate clean and start again.

    [Reply]


  5.   5. Posted By: AdlerSA
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:13 am 

    Spot on Wingers.
    Haven’t missed a race in years but I’m becoming more and more disillusioned with F1.

    I don’t want to see what they’re trying to turn it into.
    I personally don’t want to see an imposed caup but understand the need to keep costs down but the proposed cap is ludicrous – its too much too soon. The FOTA suggested a perfectly good proposal to implement it in stages and bring the cap in gradually – these blatantly ignored.
    This 2 tier system is very unappealing to me as a fan of F1 sho understand it to be the pinnacle formula in motorsport.
    No more refueling? Does that mean a 2-race Sunday. What happannedd to to Grand Prix (grand, big prize?) Too smaller races is piddle. Winners medal – even theough EVERYBODAY, teams, fans and drivers alike think its a terrible idea these 2 monkeys are imposing it anyway.

    I’d rather see F1 dissolve than have it to turn into that, and remember it the way it was – the Greatest Motorsport spectacle in the world.

    [Reply]


  6.   6. Posted By: AdlerSA
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:17 am 

    Apologies for the silly typos, sigh.

    [Reply]


  7.   7. Posted By: The Hedge Priest
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:44 am 

    I don’t think Formula One will be that different without Ferrari. I find their attitude arrogant and bullish and wouldn’t mind seeing the back of them. What would be a shame is if all the other manufacturers and drivers followed suit.

    That said I find it hard to get excited about a car company. Following drivers is part of the fun of F1, but supporting a company limited by guarantee is never going to be something that interests me.

    As long as F1 keeps the best drivers in the world then it’s still F1. Having loads of independent teams will be good for the sport, no longer will the big boys just be able to spend their way to the top.

    Max has to hold his nerve and call Ferrari and co’s bluff. A budget cap is a great idea and will make F1 more exciting in the end.

    [Reply]


  8.   8. Posted By: la-ultima-curva
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:48 am 

    it has been a bad week, no much good to come out of it at all. despite the meteoric rise of brawn and red bull, the improvement of ferrari and the consistency of alonso, means next to nothing with the now very public, very embarrassing and very disappointing conduct of the governing body and teams.
    the allure of the sport from a fans point of view has now been tainted to point where i’ve almost lost interest.

    after all, i watch racing for the spectacle of racing, not the backroom politics and soap opera that f1 has become.

    [Reply]


  9.   9. Posted By: John
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:55 am 

    Yes indeed a bad week for F1, lets hope the storm clouds blow away and we get back to business. Makes life interesting though doesnt it?

    [Reply]


  10.   10. Posted By: Stevie P
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 10:00 am 

    Well said sir…

    [Reply]


  11.   11. Posted By: TV Execs Wha?
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 10:17 am 

    James – could you expand on the TV execs part?

    I’d have thought that without Ferrari, some portion of viewership was bound to drop off.

    Then again, I must say I watch for the drivers first, and the teams second (Webber from national pride; Button and Barrichello as longtime underdog favourites).

    If F1 lost Ferrari, Toyota, Renault and RBR (+ STR?), but gained three independent teams, it might look a lot more like it did back in the early 90s… has the fan base grown over the years of supermanufacturer involvement at a rate greater than before those years?

    One other thing – your highlighted comment about F1 the other day on keeping aero standardized – would really make the sport less interesting from my perspective.

    I love the idea of appreciably different cars with appreciably different designs competing. There needs to be some level of engineering differentiation between the cars. I don’t tune in to watch glorified road cars face off; I tune in to watch the pinnacle of motor racing engineering excellence, applicability to real car technology be damned.

    [Reply]


  12.   12. Posted By: Brits on Pole
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 10:17 am 

    > Oversized handluggage – Brawn has now won 11 trophies in the first five races

    It’s an indication of the fact that it’s the last day of what has seemed a very long week that I had to think about this for about five minutes to grasp it…

    [Reply]


  13.   13. Posted By: john g
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 10:23 am 

    definitely a bad week for rubens: gets into the lead, apparently on the optimal strategy, on a clear track for most of the race, in the best car on the grid. still can’t win.

    the only whiging he can justify is about how he’s not good enough anymore.

    and actually with ferrari, renault, toyota, red bull (and hopefully BMW) standing up to the FIA in the most robust way possible, i reckon that goes into good week :)

    [Reply]


  14.   14. Posted By: David Rolfe
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 11:05 am 

    On a lighter note, surely it has to be a bad week for EJ(it) too?

    He made a total fool of himself last weekend with the rant about Kimi being unprofessional and needing to be suspended.

    Please BBC, sack Jordan asap!

    [Reply]


  15.   15. Posted By: Finn
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 11:13 am 

    With or without Ferrari, the TV execs should be looking long and hard at what F1 is worth to them. If Brawn continue to dominate this season without other teams having the chance or interest to catch up, then viewers will drop away very quickly.

    [Reply]


  16.   16. Posted By: MartinWR
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 11:14 am 

    Few people seem to understand that Max’s stance is not entirely lacking in common sense, even if the style may tend to grate.

    The problem with listening to FOTA is, firstly, they can’t agree on anything themselves, because their interests differ so greatly, and therefore they require the application of the jackboot to decide on anything. Secondly, they are at the moment dominated by the big-money teams, with Ferrari doing a good job of rabble rousing for political reasons, which I personally find obnoxious.

    No-one knows how long these big-money teams will be in F1. The manufacturers’ boards may decide at any time that they cannot afford the luxury of involvement in the sport when car aren’t selling, aren’t likely to sell, and they’re closing factories all round the world. They are in it for marketing purposes, not because racing cars are their core business. So the manufacturers’ teams could help dictate the rules of the game this year, as the obviously are hoping, yet be gone next year. They know that perfectly well, although they won’t admit it.

    Hence the governing body does need to take a long term view, as best they can, given that no-one can easily foresee the future. They probably think that, in the current economic climate, the core business racing teams are the ones that will remain in the sport long after manufacturers have decided to throw in the towel. That is probably what they are attempting to do.

    If anyone thinks you can sweet-talk sense to the monster egos that swim in F1′s pond, they are probably mistaken. In a way it has taken draconian measures for any kind of team consensus to start emerging, wrong-headed, politically motivated, and lacking in foresight, as it may be.

    [Reply]


  17.   17. Posted By: Geoff
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 11:40 am 

    This weeks winners loosers is brilliant!! I lay awake waiting for the next weeks installment!! Keep it up!!

    [Reply]


  18.   18. Posted By: Sasquatsch
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 12:54 pm 

    I am sorry, nut Rubens had no chance of winning. His lap times (with a lighter car) were not good enough to hold Button off, even with a two-stop strategy as analysis shows in this picture this picture . With the same amount of fuel Rubens was slower once Jenson got rid off Rubens right in front of him (see stints 3 and 4).

    [Reply]


  19.   19. Posted By: Phil Irwin
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 1:07 pm 

    James, am I correct in thinking this is Lewis’s third Diamond encrusted Helnet for Monaco? 2007 saw the tag ‘Monaco 2007′, 2008 was the drivers signatures in diamonds, and this year the number ’1′.
    Great collection for Lewis, assuming he gets to keep them of course.
    Phil.

    [Reply]


  20.   20. Posted By: blech
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 1:51 pm 

    James, in your opinion, are those starts really Vettel’s fault?

    I always thought that it was mostly Red Bull, going for the “optimal” strategy, instead of a more aggressive, KERS-proof one like Brawn.

    Last year McLaren had imho the same problem. There were quite a few races where a more inventive strategy could have helped them but they did everything by the book. On the other hand Ferrari this year proves that just taking risks doesn’t help, you need a Brawn errrrr brain, who knows what he’s doing.

    [Reply]


  21.   21. Posted By: Mike W
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:01 pm 

    Holy Crap Wingers, one word BINGO!

    [Reply]


  22.   22. Posted By: Retro
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:08 pm 

    What about Lewis Hamilton? I think he got bad week going on?

    Already thinking about quitting F1 after he doesn’t have winning car and because of he did do in lie-gate.

    Also this might be good week for F1 if teams can get their voice heard and Max would get slap to his fingers.

    [Reply]


  23.   23. Posted By: Jon
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:09 pm 

    James I don’t understand why you don’t mention RBR more in the threats to leave.

    They have arguably the most credability in their threats because they are currently in the best position they have ever been in. And have two teams. Unlike the others that bigger names yes (and bigger brands) but are struggling this season and their threats could look like sour grapes (because they aren’t winning). BMW has been spoken about more then RBR, and BMW haven’t even threatened to leave yet.

    [Reply]


  24.   24. Posted By: F1 fan
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:13 pm 

    Well if they got 3 points in a bad race, what will they do in a good race? 10?

    [Reply]


  25.   25. Posted By: James Allen
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:17 pm 

    Mmm, good points, but yes he is losing ground at the starts and the KERS is exacerbating that.

    [Reply]


  26.   26. Posted By: James Allen
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:18 pm 

    I dunno, I find it kind of unnecessary, but blingy for me. Now Lewis’ fault that tie up has existed for years with the team

    [Reply]


  27.   27. Posted By: DanB
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:26 pm 

    41 points from 45 is impressive in anyones book – JB’s worst result so far is a 3rd place! When did we last see that sort of winning consistency from any driver in F1?

    [Reply]


  28.   28. Posted By: Kenny
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 2:49 pm 

    Your comments are spot on, except for the bit about Indy being Mickey Mouse. For some reason, the further F1 sinks into the gutter, the more mud F1 fans sling at the IRL. I fail to see what one has to do with the other.

    You need to watch some races, Wingers. The main event is coming up later this month. You’ll see that Mickey has been living on the east side of the Atlantic for a few years now.

    [Reply]


  29.   29. Posted By: MartinWR
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 3:06 pm 

    Re Rubens in Spain, I can’t help wondering whether the team might actually have planned for him to win the race. Ross actually said that, at one point when interviewed, though I assumed that wasn’t quite what he actually meant. Now I begin to wonder. Rubens was certainly pretty aggressive to Button in the first corner, in going ahead. I notice that Jense is normally extremely careful himself at that point this season, gives everyone else a wide berth, going round the outside. Could explain why Rubens was so choked, if he had been handed a chance to win due to his practice performance. Button really blew him away, fair and square.

    [Reply]


  30.   30. Posted By: Kirk
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 3:10 pm 

    Very well said.

    [Reply]


  31.   31. Posted By: MartinWR
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 3:18 pm 

    Whether you agree with Eddie Jordan or not, this is a guy who has run some reasonably successful racing teams, and he has a quite different way of looking at the sport. I like hearing what a team owner thinks for a change, even if I don’t necessarily agree with it. Straight from the jaws of the Piranha, so to speak.

    [Reply]


  32.   32. Posted By: Stevie P
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 3:54 pm 

    I’m not sure that would happen this season, as the current “phoenix from the ashes” vibe associated to BrawnGP should\will continue until the end of the championship.

    Plus Red Bull are breathing down their necks; Ferrari and Macca will get closer, as seen in Spain and Bahrain respectively, as will BMW. It will tighten up and we will get other race winners… I hope (although I’m quite happy watching BrawnGP win!)

    If Ferrari or others do decide to depart from F1, they’ll want to go out on a high… and will develop heavily, knowing that they’re not around for the following season.

    If Brawn went on next season to dominate and perhaps the year after, then I could see viewer levels dropping away… but I can’t see that happening.

    It won’t affect the people who love the sport though (like us, who post here), they will still watch, surely?

    [Reply]


  33.   33. Posted By: Richard Mee
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 4:57 pm 

    Personally I couldn’t agree more with EJ on that one – I admire his balls for saying it. Kimi’s earning £20mio a season… think about that, and then ask whether he’s earning it whilst he’s putting his shorts on and going to the freezer for another Magnum.

    Stuff him.

    [Reply]


  34.   34. Posted By: Mr T
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 5:27 pm 

    spot on (except the a1gp and indy bit!)

    [Reply]


  35.   35. Posted By: MartinWR
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 5:38 pm 

    This has now got to be an even worse week for Formula One now. Ferrari have decided that if they can’t get their own way they will take the FIA to court, and wreck Formula One for everyone next year.

    This is the inevitable consequence of repeatedly giving in to Ferrari’s blackmail, and subsidising this very rich company for years to race on an unequal footing with all the other teams. What a thoroughly nasty, underhand, arrangement this has been. This whole fiasco is a very good reason why all the teams should start from a level playing field in future, like competitors in any normal sport. Unfortunately that probably won’t happen and the issue will be fudged so Bernie can keep his ill-gotten gains rolling in. His wife’s divorce settlement alone could probably finance most of the F1 teams, under the cap, to put the rape of the sport into perspective.

    Having observed F1 for a good long while, Ferrari mean no more and no less to me than any of the other iconic teams that are no longer racing: Lotus, Brabham, Cooper, Tyrrell, and so on. They are NOT bigger than Formula One, any more than those others were. Times change, and the world moves on. So must Formula One.

    [Reply]


  36.   36. Posted By: The Apricot
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 5:44 pm 

    I think a video interview on the BBC website suggested that this year’s will be auctioned off for charity. Not too sure what happened to the others in the past though.

    [Reply]


  37.   37. Posted By: Jon W
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 5:54 pm 

    AdlerSA, I don’t know you’ve got the idea that no re-fueling means two short races instead of one race, but it doesn’t – prior to 1994 there was no re-fueling and they used to manage to go the full distance then – with larger engines than they have now too.

    They will simply design the cars with larger fuel tanks that will hold enough fuel for a full race distance.

    [Reply]


  38.   38. Posted By: Andrea
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 6:29 pm 

    Dear James, hope you don’t mind, but I’d like to add F1 fans to the bad week list… :-(

    [Reply]


  39.   39. Posted By: Soeren
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 6:55 pm 

    Vettel COULD have won the last two races, not the last three. In China he DID win!

    [Reply]


  40.   40. Posted By: sean
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 9:05 pm 

    Well I hope you are all correct about FERRARI that when the largest crowd puller in the game leave’s that nothing changes.Im sure the tracks will still be full the Tv ratings across the board will peck and sponsors will be falling over themselves to through money at the new breed of car and team, leading F1 into a brighter future and MAX & BERNIE will be vindicated in there decision to upturn the sport.Yeah right
    Bad week for the fans again!

    [Reply]


  41.   41. Posted By: phil c
        Date: May 15th, 2009 @ 10:02 pm 

    Spot on. I hope the teams all leave and start there own championship. It is the manufacture teams that pump the $$ directly and indirectly with fans in the sport. Bernie has developed a model, which is financely flawed i might ad, and max things he can make billion dollar calls without consulting the stake holders, the team.

    Max you are the MAN THAT KILLED F1.

    [Reply]


  42.   42. Posted By: Top Posts « WordPress.com
        Date: May 16th, 2009 @ 12:57 am 

    [...] Good week/Bad week Good week for: Jenson Button – Four wins from five, only four points dropped. He’s running out of people to [...] [...]


  43.   43. Posted By: ROBATCLAXBY
        Date: May 16th, 2009 @ 10:47 am 

    WINGERS, I agree with most of the things you say, but I was under the impression that the FIA have bought Ferrari many, many, times over.! or am I being cynical?

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply





COUNTDOWN TO NEXT RACE
Strategy Report
Innovation and Technology brought to you by TATA Communications
Senna DVD
Download the Chequered Flag Podcast here
MTS
Darren Heath
Sport Right Now